NBA Finals Betting Heats Up with Series Tied Before Game 3

As the NBA Finals shift to Indianapolis for Game 3, sportsbooks and bettors are recalibrating their expectations. The Indiana Pacers head home tied 1-1 with the Oklahoma City Thunder, a scenario that tilts momentum slightly but precariously in Indiana’s favor. The split in Oklahoma City not only hands the Pacers temporary home-court advantage—it also injects uncertainty into betting markets.

Before Game 1, the Thunder entered the series as slight favorites, with most sportsbooks placing them around -135 to win the title. Indiana, despite an explosive postseason run, was tagged as the underdog at +115. But the Pacers’ stunning Game 1 road win—secured by a last-second jumper from Tyrese Haliburton—shifted lines considerably, with some books moving Indiana into favorite status before Game 2.

After Oklahoma City’s commanding 123–107 win in Game 2, the odds have evened out again. Most major sportsbooks now list the Finals as a near toss-up. The Thunder sit at around -120 to win the series, while the Pacers are hovering at even money (+100), a reflection of how uncertain and stylistically complex this matchup has become.

The Fluctuating Odds

Indiana

IN Online Casinos

IN Sports Betting

Gambling Laws

IN Online Poker

IN Land Casinos

33 Casinos

All Casinos

Indiana’s offense thrives in the paint. In the playoffs, they've averaged 46 paint points per win. In their five losses? Just 36. That split was glaring in Game 2, when they managed just four points in the paint in the first half. That figure—almost unthinkably low for a team built on interior penetration—helps explain why Oklahoma City covered the spread with ease.

Conversely, Oklahoma City has built its defense around exactly this kind of suppression. No team allowed fewer points in the paint during the regular season, and the Finals have followed that trend. Led by Luguentz Dort’s relentless on-ball defense and Chet Holmgren’s rim protection, the Thunder have forced Indiana into low-percentage shots from the perimeter—an uncomfortable place for a team used to generating rhythm from the inside out.

This tactical clash is driving under/over bets as well. Game 1 narrowly hit the over (218 total points), while Game 2 soared past the total with 230. Bettors should watch for Indiana’s paint production early in Game 3; if it trends upward, the over becomes more appealing. If the Thunder continue to dictate the terms, the under could regain value.

The Home Court Factor

Indiana hasn’t hosted an NBA Finals game since 2000. That long drought means Bankers Life Fieldhouse will be electric Wednesday night. Oddsmakers are giving the Pacers a modest 3.5-point edge for Game 3—standard for a home-court bump, but still reflective of doubts about Indiana’s ability to adjust to Oklahoma City’s pressure defense.

Tyrese Haliburton, who has been the focal point of the Thunder’s defensive scheme, acknowledges the challenge: “They’re flying around,” he said. “We have to get downhill and make them collapse.” His ability to regain control of the tempo is pivotal—not only for Indiana’s game plan but for any bettor eyeing the Pacers’ individual or team props.
Where the Smart Money’s Going

With the series reset and the Thunder reasserting themselves in Game 2, sharp bettors appear to be leaning slightly toward Oklahoma City in the full series market. However, there’s growing value in specific props—especially regarding pace of play and team scoring.

• Pacers Team Total: Bettors might consider the under unless Indiana shows consistent paint penetration early.
• Thunder Paint Points: With Indiana’s interior defense still shaky, Oklahoma City may continue to exploit this edge.
• Haliburton Assists: If the Pacers recommit to an inside-out game, Haliburton’s passing numbers should climb.

The Bottom Line

Game 3 could define the trajectory of the Finals—and the outlook for bettors. If Indiana reclaims its identity and feeds off the energy of a long-starved home crowd, the Pacers could reassert themselves as more than a sentimental underdog. But if the Thunder continue to dictate pace and paint control, they’ll regain series control—and tilt the betting odds back in their favor.

For now, the numbers are tight, the margins are thin, and for sportsbooks and fans alike, the Finals are shaping up to be a bettor’s dream: unpredictable, tactical, and razor-close.